Conservatism is Dead!

Blogorama

 Blogarama - The Blog Directory

Google Ads

AdSense referral

BlogHub

Blog Directory & Search engine

Google Ads II

Google Ads III

Search Box

 

Calendar

««Aug 2008»»
SMTWTFS
      12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31

Mailing List

PayPal

Universal Human Brotherhood

Debunking the right

News outlets

Blogs

Groups

Police Brutality and the death of Carol Gotbaum

posted Tuesday, 2 October 2007

Carol Gotbaum was a victim of police brutality. It seems that she panicked when she missed a flight and was taken into police custody for disorderly conduct. While under arrest, the police ignored her cries for help and she died, supposedly of asphyxiation. Except, the problem is, the "official story" was that she had a shackle chain around her throat, which is difficult to comprehend given the fact that she was handcuffed the whole time.

Last week, Bob Herbert wrote that the cities that reduced crime in recent years did so by bringing professionalism to their police departments and reaching out to neighborhoods that they did not normally reach out to. It seems that the exact opposite is the case here. At the airports, the security is the last line of defense against a terrorist attack. Therefore, it is vitally important that they are able to gain the confidence of people, something that will not be accomplished by the kind of brutality that seemed to be the case here.

The government should conduct a review of airport security measures and ensure that all security guards are properly trained to handle such passengers and to recognize when medical emergencies exist. They should also ensure that they are all properly trained on when to use force and when not to.

tags:          

links: digg this    del.icio.us    technorati    reddit




1. belloscm left...
Thursday, 4 October 2007 1:30 pm

Your info is both inaccurate and OBE.

First of all, Carol Gotbaum was apprehended by members of the Phoenix PD, not "Security Guards." Additionally, the approx 16 inch shackle chain (attached to her handcuffs) was not "around her throat", but was pressing against the front of her throat as she apparently tried to either reposition her cuffed hands from her back to her front or, to escape her restraints. Her attempts apparently resulted in self-induced, positional asphxiation.

Practically no one, with the exception of you, has alledged police brutality. While it is probably true that she was handled in an abrupt and firm manner (not necessarily illegal or inappropriate), that does not arise to the level of brutality. Before you go there, it is of absolutely no consequence that this "small" woman was taken down and forceably taken under control by three officers. That is not only standard procedure, it was the responsible thing to do, given Gotbaum's lack of cooperation and wildly irrational, possibly alcohol-induced behavior. Please do Google for the accounts of witnesses whose statements have not been cherry-picked by the Gotbaum family lawyers.

WRT your attempts to conflate the Herbert piece to the subject at hand; I didn't know that middle-aged, substance abusing white woman were a constituency that were ignored by law enforcement outreach efforts.

P.S. Your anti-cops undies are showing.


2. Eternal Hope left...
Thursday, 4 October 2007 11:02 pm

First of all, she was originally subdued by airport guards, not the Phoenix PD; they were summoned later; that was in the linked story. Secondly of all, if the chain was not wrapped around her throat, that only makes the matter worse as far as the police in this case were concerned.

But this is typical right-wing blame the victim rhetoric that is at work here. While you may be right that the way she was subdued was standard proceedure in this case, it would seem like in this case, the cops went well beyond the standard proceedures afterwards. And they never should have left her alone after taking her to the holding cell; common sense would tell you that such a prisoner would risk strangling herself when she was like that. And your implication that she may have been on other substances is total nonsense; there is no evidence of that whatsoever.

While we don't know everything about what happened, what we do know does not pass the smell test. There has to be a careful review about what happened, from the conduct of the officers, to the way uncooperative people should be handled, to the way that the handcuffs are designed. This tragic death never should have happened.